Showing posts with label Steinmetz v. Shutterstock Corp NYSD DCMA Sec. 512(c) Takedown Defense Bar By Service Provider September 27 2022. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Steinmetz v. Shutterstock Corp NYSD DCMA Sec. 512(c) Takedown Defense Bar By Service Provider September 27 2022. Show all posts

Tuesday, September 27, 2022

In The "It Turns Out..." Department: Shutterstock Not Liable Where It Promptly Removes Image, After Indian Interloper's Repeated Wrongful Uploads.


We first mentioned this case on a snowy, quiet Sunday night. . . in January 2022.

What we hadn't known then, because Shutterstock hadn't yet filed an answer, was that the actual infringer was a someone (or "someones" -- an illicit company) located behind firewalls in India, who had repeatedly removed the photographer's copyright marks -- and repeatedly reposted the infringing work (they got paid a few times on downloads of the infringing image, but now that has ended, too).

Each time Shutterstock was made aware that the Indian contributor had reposted it, Shutterstock removed it -- doing its part under the DMCA takedown provisions.

So, sadly. . . Steinmetz is likely left without a meaningful remedy here because it will be nearly impossible to sort out, and find the repeat infringer, in India, behind the proxy servers / anonymizers. But Shutterstock, for its part, will not pay the infringer for downloads. So the infringer is unlikely to continue in a course of conduct that nets no monetary windfall.

Here is the 17 page opinion. It is well-reasoned.

. . .Summary judgment for Shutterstock under DMCA Sec. 512(c). . . .


Now you know. Onward to a lovely fall evening here. . . special dinner up!

नमस्ते